20. Phoenicia to Silver Hollow Notch

Section 20: Phoenicia to Silver Hollow Notch

Quick Facts

Distance: 11.5 miles
Parks: Phoenicia-Mt. Tobias Wild Forest
Maps: Interactive Map, Catskill Trails (map 141)
Print-Friendly Version: Link

General Description

The Long Path leaves Phoenicia on public roads, paralleling the Esopus Creek. The trail then climbs up the south side of Tremper Mountain, following an old tote road to the former state fire tower. From there, it heads toward Carl Mountain and circles it to descend to Warner Creek before going over Edgewood Mountain to Silver Hollow Notch. This section begins a long stretch between supply points. From Phoenicia to Palenville is over 40 miles. In this distance, only two roads are crossed. Neither has stores within 4 miles of the crossings. There is an unbridged stream crossing at the 8.25 mile mark (Warner Creek) that is dangerous to impassible at high water.


Take the New York State Thruway to Exit 19 (Kingston). Follow NY Route 28 west for 23 miles to Phoenicia. Turn right at the second turn to Phoenicia (Bridge Street). Follow Bridge Street across the Esopus Creek to Main Street in Phoenicia.


0.00  Village of Phoenicia (parking available on Main Street or behind the Phoenicia Pharmacy on NY Route 214). (unlocated)
1.30  There is a DEC parking lot on Plank Road (Ulster County Route 40), 0.3 miles south of where the Long Path leaves the road. (42.06599°, -74.30312°)
11.50  There is parking about 1.2 miles from the end of this section, off NY Route 214 near Notch Inn Road. ( 42.14324°, -74.21215°)


3.15  Baldwin Memorial Lean-to.
4.00  Tremper Mountain Lean-to.

Trail Description

0.00  From the intersection of Bridge Street and Main Street in Phoenicia continue east on Main Street (Ulster County Route 40), following the north side of Esopus Creek. In the spring, the Esopus is filled with white water canoers and kayakers, as well as trout fishermen. The Esopus is one of the most famous trout streams in America. In the summer, the primary recreational use of the creek is by people who ride lazily downstream in inner tubes.

1.30  The Long Path arrives at the unmarked beginning of the old fire warden's road leading up Tremper Mountain on the left. This was the trailhead for the Phoenicia Trail before it was moved 0.3 miles east to a new parking lot in the late 90s. Turn left following the wide road steeply uphill for about 100 yards to a junction with the Phoenicia Trail. Red markers to the right lead 0.3 miles to the parking area on Ulster County Route 40. Continue straight ahead on red markers following the fire warden's road to the abandoned state fire tower. The grade varies between steep and gradual. On the steeper sections, the trail is rocky and eroded. For most of the way, the trail passes through a mixed hardwood and hemlock forest.

2.05  Pass rock ledges on the left.

2.15  Pass a seasonal spring on left, which is reliable in all but the driest times.

2.20  The trail passes an abandoned bluestone quarry on the left. Bluestone mining was once one of the primary industries in the Catskills. As you pass the quarry, you can see the layering that made bluestone an easy mineral to mine. Past the quarry the trail levels off, crosses several woods roads, and begins a series of switchbacks.

2.95  The trail sidehills through a steep slope with rock walls on the right and a steep drop on the left. After a short level stretch, the trail again begins a steep climb.

3.15  A side trail to the right leads to the Baldwin Memorial Lean-to. In another 250 feet, pass an undependable pipe spring 50 feet to the left of the trail.

3.65  After a switchback, the trail climbs to the top of the ridge, and then follows it the rest of the way to the summit. Here the forest is less mature; consequently, there is more undergrowth.

4.00  Pass the Tremper Mountain Lean-to on the left.

4.05  Reach the flat, level summit of Tremper Mountain, with an abandoned state fire tower, formerly used by fire observers with two-way radios. These towers were placed on top of selected mountains in the early 1900s after a series of fires devastated the mountains. More recently, the fire towers have been replaced by aircraft patrols. This fire tower has been restored and is open to the public. To the right of the tower is an open area that affords a view of the Devil's Path when the leaves are down. Continuing past the tower, the Long Path passes through a cleared area and then begins to descend, now following the blue-blazed Warner Creek Trail. It passes through a fairly open forest, with a base of blackberry rambles.


Frost growing from the rocks. 2001 [HERB CHONG]

4.30  The trail enters a more mature forest, with little undergrowth. It continues to descend along the ridge top towards the col between Tremper Mountain and Carl Mountain. Initially, the trail follows the eastern slope of the ridge, with seasonal views through the trees over the Devil's Path to the north.

4.95  The trail levels out and then begins a gradual climb of the north peak of Tremper Mountain. For the most part, the trail stays about 200 vertical feet below the top of the ridge, following the western slopes.

5.80  After passing through a hemlock grove, the trail descends along the eastern side of the ridge.

6.20  Reach the col between Tremper Mountain and Carl Mountain. Here, the yellow-marked Willow Trail turns right, leaving the ridge, descending steeply 1.6 miles through Hoyt Hollow to Jessop Road, and in another mile to the Willow Post Office. Continue ahead on the blue-marked Warner Creek Trail following an old, gently sloping woods road with little elevation change.

6.60  Bear left leaving the woods road and begin a moderate descent through open hardwoods. When the leaves are down, there are views to Tremper Mountain and the Central Catskills beyond.

7.00  The trail eases onto a wide bench and contours to the right around Carl Mountain, slowly gaining elevation.

7.35  Begin a steep descent to Warner Creek, passing a series of cataracts in the seasonal stream to the right of the trail. There are many switchbacks on the way down.


Bluestone quarry. 2011 [JAKOB FRANKE]

7.60  The trail descends some stone steps into the bed of a seasonal stream. Continue across the streambed to meet the terminus of an old quarry road and follow it. In about 0.2 miles, there is a bluestone quarry on the right. Once past the quarry, the trail descends again for a few hundred feet.

7.90  Pass a stone foundation to right. It is in open park-like surroundings and is a perfect area for a campsite. Continue gently downhill towards Warner Creek.

8.25  The trail crosses Warner Creek on a gravel bar in a hemlock grove. There is no bridge for this crossing, making it dangerous at medium or high water.


Warner Creek. 2009 [JAKOB FRANKE]

8.30  Reach a woods road and turn right to follow it. There is a small stream within 500 feet located in a hemlock grove.

8.60  Turn left, leaving the woods road, and begin the climb to the summit of Edgewood Mountain. The ascent is moderate to steep through open hardwoods and an occasional hemlock grove.

9.25  Pass a black birch tree with a large burl in its trunk. Just beyond, the trail joins a faint old quarry road and steepens.

9.55  The trail reaches the broad ridge and turns right to follow it uphill.

10.00  The trail traverses a grassy area.

10.50  Pass a large bog on right.

10.70  The trail crosses the broad summit of Edgewood Mountain. There are no views. Shortly beyond, begin a steep descent through rocky ledges toward Silver Hollow Notch.

11.00  Reach a view into Warner Creek Valley with Olderbark Mountain opposite.

11.20  Reach a view to the south over Warner Creek Valley.

11.50  Arrive at Silver Hollow Notch and the end of Section 20. To continue, cross the road and follow the blue blazes. Turning to the left leads in about a mile to Notch Inn Road and NY Route 214.


Previous Section: Section 19
Next Section: Section 21

Comment: Please be relevant, civil, non-commercial.

Gedalyamil's picture

When you journey to Ithaca pray that the Path is Long, full of adventure, full of discovery…………and if you find her poor upon arrival, Ithaca will not have disappointed you…….without Ithaca you would never have set forth on the road. These are excerpts from the poem ‘Ithaca’ by C. P. Cavafy. When I raced up the I-87 NYS Thruway this morning toward Phoenicia (ah those Greeks!) I had the fear of Marcy in me. No, Marcy is not my wife or mother-in-law or some random vixen. Marcy stands proudly as the tallest peak in the Adirondacks and the highest mountain in New York State. The story goes back 25 years. My brother and a couple of friends and I drove ~5 hours from Upper West Side of Manhattan to the Adirondacks high peaks region to climb Marcy one glorious summer day. Another 4 hours and a few pints of dripping sweat later and we were literally within 5 feet of the Marcy summit, all we needed to do was climb up the remaining exposed rock. We politely gave way to a cadre of descending hikers, when my friend Izzy struck up a conversation with one gentleman. He discovered that one of these descending hikers was a fellow West-Sider. What street do you live on? Which Apartment? Who is the Doorman? Which Gastroenterologist do you use? Etc. By the time Izzy and this guy finished exchanging notes, the pale-blue heavens changed to octogenarian-grey and just as quickly lightening was bolting in the Adirondack sky. We quickly left the exposed rock for lower ground. The storm intensified. To make a long story short, we never made it to the summit of Marcy and I still haven’t to this day. In my family, when we prematurely abort any endeavor – from grand to small – we say we “Marcy’ed” it. There was a nor-Easter in the forecast for Phoenicia today. I did not want to Marcy Stage 20 of the LP on account of being unable to traverse Warner Creek. I met my cabbie Kevin from Woodstock TownCar near the Notch Inn Road terminus where I left my automobile. 6 miles and $60 later I was at the intersection of Main St. and Bridge St. in downtown Phoenicia for the start of the hike. The Nor’Easter was thankfully late on arrival. The short road walk along the Esopus Creek was pleasant as the blue water looked content against the overcast skies. As I entered the woods, I was quickly enveloped in the pre-storm tranquility and a misty solitude. I was so comfortable hiking, I hardly noticed the steep climb up Mt. Tremper. I tuned into my daily Talmud podcast. The topic of discussion was the sequestering of the high priest for one week before he performed his most sacred annual duty (Yoma 4). There was a disputation if this was primarily for the purpose of education or solitude and introspection. This hike today made me favor the latter. Then I was flabbergasted! It was as if the ancients were speaking directly to me and knew that I would be hiking this very section of the LP today under pre-storm conditions. The Talmud discussed the term “Shevil”, which means ‘hiking path’ in paleo-Aramaic as well as in modern Hebrew. I remember 30 years ago when my brother endowed the Devil’s Path with the Hebrew appellation “Shevil Ha’azazel”. Of the many thousands of pages of Talmud, this is the only place where ‘Shevil’ is discussed - and in the context of clouds and water crossings!! Too coincidental to be a coincidence!! And then, it was if I was living out the Bible on the LP. My ascent into the misty clouds on the summit of Mt. Tremper was reminiscent of the Talmud’s narrative of Moses’ ascent up the ‘Shevil’ of Mount Sinai into the divine cloud. Similarly, my crossing of the raging Warner Creek on a stone path paralleled the Talmud’s description of the ‘Shevil’ God created for the ancient Israelites to traverse the Red Sea. However, after crossing Warner Creek all inspiration disappeared. The misty rain turned into a torrid down-pour. I quickly become soakin’ wet. My poncho was rendered useless. My boots were drenched and my phone-based GPS navigation device became non-functional from the moisture. The trail was well marked, only in need of routine seasonal clearing of fallen limbs along the switchbacks, but I felt extremely vulnerable having hiked the rest of the LP with the benefit of Avenza maps. Visibility was poor. I was hiking tree-to-tree, blue-marker-to-blue-marker. I still had my spikes on from yesterday and these proved useful in gaining traction against the wet terrain. Pea-sized hail began to rain from the heavens on the summit of Mt. Edgewood. I was in distress. Where was my golden calf? How had I sinned? Then I remembered it was my wife Annie’s birthday and my niece Gabi’s Sweet 16. It was too late for me to tune into Gabi’s virtual Sweet 16 party, but at least I sent my regrets on my way home. I reassured Annie that there is no better present than a faithful and doting husband. I made it home intact. Thank God I didn't Marcy this one!